The Best Eyebrow Products For Redheads

Why is it so hard to find the right brow products for red hair?

Redheads, both natural & dyed, come in endless shades, and often brow products for "red" or "auburn" hair can lean too orange or warm. And, to make matters worse, it seems like the best ones get discontinued.


It Cosmetics Brow Power Super Skinny Waterproof Brow Pencil in Universal Auburn

Sadly, It Cosmetics has discontinued our #1 pick, but you can still find it deeply discounted on Amazon.  Why we love it: For those with dark brows, the tone of this microfine pencil adds the right amount of color & definition for perfectly shade matched brows.

Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz in Chocolate


Chocolate is the first brow shade that I tried on the recommendation of a makeup artist friend, and it's a shade that I have reached for time & time again. This color is better darker to auburn tones with darker natural brows.

Hourglass Arch Brow Sculpting Pencil in Warm Blonde


When natural-looking brows are the goal, Warm Blonde is the shade I reach for. It subtly defines my brows without adding anything except a subtle warmth & softness. The shade is so perfect that it's practically undetectable.

NYX Lift & Snatch Waterproof Brow Tint Pen


Although NYX does have a dedicated Auburn color in this line, I find that these shades run too orange/warm. Caramel, on the other hand, is warm but creates the most natural, hair-like strokes. I recommend applying after a strong hold brow gel for maximum results.